facebook twitter twitter

"Trouble the Water" Makes a Splash at IC

Written by Alyssa Figueroa

"Trouble the Water" Makes a Splash at IC

Tia Lessin and Carl Deal wanted to make a movie about Louisiana National Guardsmen who’d fought in Iraq and were now being asked to help restore order in New Orleans in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.

Instead, a chance meeting at a Red Cross center with a young couple who’d filmed the disaster on a camcorder led them to direct and produce Trouble the Water, an Academy Award-nominated documentary which screened to a packed house at Emerson Suites last month.

"They lived through a nightmare."

With no sit-down interviews, no statistics, and no explanatory subtitles, Trouble the Water doesn’t feel like a traditional documentary. The film covers the lives of Ninth Ward residents Kimberley and Scott Roberts from the day before Katrina through the storm itself and the two years following. The story highlights the struggle the people of New Orleans went through while still sharing their sense of optimism. 

The underlying message was also clear, as Kimberley’s sister states in the movie: “If you don’t have money and you don’t have status, you don’t have government.”

"But the real disaster was about to begin."

With unanswered 911 calls and no emergency rescue system, Katrina’s victims were left to seek help on their own. Even a Navy base with vacant rooms refused to shelter victims of the disaster, with soldiers eventually threatening to open fire.

Sponsored by the Park Center for Independent Media, the screening ended with a Q&A session with the filmmakers.

“The government abandoned New Orleans before the hurricane hit,” Lessin told the audience, citing the feds’ failure to prepare for rescue relief and their knowledge of the levees’ inability to withstand the storm as examples. This, she said, was occurring all while the U.S. was spending $350 million daily on the war in Iraq.

But Lessin said their goal with the movie was not to portray misery, but the real story of the city’s residents. “You can find humor in tragedy,” Lessin said. “I love to laugh and to make people laugh ... and there are lots of high spirits in New Orleans.”

“I was really impressed,” said Karla Berberich ’11.  “I thought it was really unique and probably the best way to tell the story of Katrina. It certainly made me feel like I was there.”

In a much more intimate setting the following day in the Park Auditorium, Lessin and Deal led a discussion of the pros and cons of making independent films. They showed clips from their past work and from their upcoming documentary Dragnet, about the deportation of supposed “terrorists” from the U.S.

Lessin said she enjoyed seeing and talking with students who may continue in her path.

“It’s a shot in the arm for us and for me to see a new generation of budding journalists and documentary filmmakers and independent media voices out there,” she said.  “I’m excited about seeing their work in the future and passing the torch on in hopes they have the ideals and the energy and awareness to get their voices heard.”



Are you a prospective student with college planning questions? Then myIthaca has got you covered.

Sign-Up Learn More
Copyright © Ithaca College. All rights reserved.

Fuse is a student produced publication about the Ithaca College experience. All content in the print and web versions of Fuse is developed by current Ithaca College students in a breadth of different areas of study.