facebook twitter twitter

Straight from the Tap?

Written by Meredith Farley

Bottled water has long been a point of contention between environmentalists and those who prize convenience and efficiency. Last year Marian Brown, special assistant to the provost and VPAA at Ithaca College, facilitated a project for Ithaca College’s Resource and Environmental Management Program that compared bottled water to tap water.

Taste testers were given three samples of water, marked only as X, Y, and Z. They were asked to rate the taste of the water without knowing whether it was from a bottle or a tap. The tastings took place on IC's campus and around the Ithaca area, in spots like the Ithaca Farmer's Market. In four out of the five tests, the tasters actually preferred the tap water.

Ithaca College and the Town of Ithaca have access to great tasting tap water. The study was meant to highlight the palatability of Ithaca’s tap water and encourage IC students and Ithacans to take advantage it.

There are many reasons that bottled water has become a trend of the 21st century, and most of them have nothing to do with necessity. As large companies use their advertising dollars to push bottled water, the huge campaigns they've launched have doubtlessly affected American consumers. The sale of bottled water has quadrupled in the last 20 years. As the clear plastic bottles become more ubiquitous, their impact on our environment becomes greater.

“No water is ever completely free of chemical contaminants, except for distilled water, and most folks would hate the taste of that, because one's palate actually tends to prefer certain natural chemicals in water like calcium, and other minerals,” explains Brown.

“Certainly selecting to purchase water products that are bottled farther away - whether from quality spring sources or from purified municipal water sources--and transported to the region for local purchase--have environmental impacts that simply filling up a reusable water bottle at the drinking fountain down the hall don't have,” says Brown. “We have talked about installing additional filtration devices on drinking fountains to remove some of the other water treatment chemicals that people sometimes object to, if they are over a certain tastable threshold.”

Though many people might grab a bottle of water because they think it's safer than drinking from the tap, city water actually passes through rigorous testing and must meet FDA standards, which usually follow the recommendations of the EPA. “In terms of water quality safety issues and open disclosure of chemicals in the water product, the best option is to choose municipal water sources,” says Brown.



Are you a prospective student with college planning questions? Then myIthaca has got you covered.

Sign-Up Learn More
Copyright © Ithaca College. All rights reserved.

Fuse is a student produced publication about the Ithaca College experience. All content in the print and web versions of Fuse is developed by current Ithaca College students in a breadth of different areas of study.